Homemade Classic White Sandwich Bread
I've been baking since before I met my husband ten years ago. He eats gluten but appreciates my baking efforts and gives me feedback on texture compared to gluten products, which he consumes regularly on his lunch break at work in the form of sandwiches. I'm a photographer too but he graces the wall of his office with blown-up cell phone shots of half-eaten sandwiches and burritos from his favorite shops. He likes my baked goods, sure, but who can blame him for going for gluten? This last few weeks as I was testing this recipe, however, something shifted. I finally heard these words: "you can make me this every weekend for the rest of my life."
I know my husband likes a bread I made when he immediately plans what sandwich to make from it. Well, he's done that for every test loaf I've made for this bread. A few days ago, in fact, he ate a breakfast sandwich with this bread, got catered burgers for lunch at work, then came home and requested a steak sandwich on the fresh loaf of bread I made. I mean, I knew he liked sandwiches, but now I have a sandwich bread he will consume multiple times daily.
I have not attempted a vegan version of this recipe yet, but I will work on it. There is something about the pure protein of eggs that's difficult to replicate. Also, I'm finding that the egg and the milk are a big part of what make this bread white. So the vegan version might end up being a different recipe altogether, once I attempt it.
Classic White Sandwich Bread Recipe
Contains dairy and egg. Gum free, rice free, soy free.
Mix time: 10-20 minutes
Rest & Remix time: 30 minutes
Rise time: 45-90 minutes
Bake time: 60 minutes
Total time: 2 hours 45 minutes +
Mix in a large bowl or the bowl of a stand mixer:
450g Rustic White Bread Flour Blend:
150g tapioca starch
150g potato starch
100g sorghum flour
50g millet flour
25g roughly ground psyllium husk OR psyllium powder (I grind my own in a whirly blade coffee grinder)
24g baking sugar (2Tbsp) (this is a fine granulated sugar - regular granulated is likely okay)
8.5g salt (1.5tsp)
3g active dry yeast (1 tsp)
When the dry ingredients are well blended, pour into the bowl:
100g egg whites (for me this is the whites of three eggs)
450g whole milk, warmed to 100°f/38°c
Mix the wet ingredients into the dry ingredients until smooth by hand or with the paddle attachment of a stand mixer. Cover and let rest for 30 minutes.
While waiting, prep a sandwich loaf pan by buttering it thoroughly. I use a 4x4x9 inch pullman pan for this recipe to get a high rise.
Once rested, the batter will have stiffened into a dough. Mix again with a stand mixer or mix by hand until it relaxes a bit. Add:
12g unsalted butter (1 Tbsp), softened but not melted (optional)
12g apple cider vinegar (1 Tbsp) (optional, or sub lemon juice)
Mix until a shaggy, loose dough forms. Turn out the dough into your greased pullman or loaf pan. Smooth down the dough to flatten and distribute evenly to the edges. Cover and let rise at room temperature (68-70°f/20-21°c). Mark the side of the pan with some dough so you can see what a 50% rise (by dough volume) will look like.
Let rise about 50%, anywhere from 45minutes to an hour and a half.
Melted butter (or an egg wash with one of the egg yolks whisked with a splash of milk)
Bake, covered, at 425°f/220°c for 15 minutes. (The best way to cover a loaf pan is by inverting another loaf pan on top of it. But tin foil or a pan cover can work just as well.)
Take the cover off and turn down the heat to 375°f/190°c and bake anther 40 minutes, uncovered.
When the bread is baked and golden, carefully tip it out of the hot tin and bake another 5 minutes directly on the oven rack. It's done if it sounds hollow when tapped on the bottom and sides. (If not then bake another 5 minutes straight on the rack.) Place on a cooling rack and let cool completely before slicing.
Enjoy!
Comments
Thanks for any help you can provide, and again, I am so very grateful for all you do! Shari Shaw
I just went to slice the white sandwich loaf and it is *also gummy on each side of the loaf* although not quite as wide a band as along the bottom. The top is perfect. The sides caved in a little bit (less this time than with the first loaf). I wish I'd taken a photo. I'd love to nail this loaf! Thanks.
I cut the recipe in half but accidentally used the full amount of yeast. I love the ethereally light crumb, but unfortunately the loaf sunk dramatically in the middle once out of the oven and compressed the bottom.
I did cut it when slightly warm, but it had already sunk quite a lot, and was wobbly when cutting - it didn't have the structure to hold itself up.
I subbed amaranth flour for millet. Marked the 50% proof line with dough so I don't think it was overproofed. Baked in a toaster oven in a small Pullman pan, initially covered with foil.
Would love to make this again with a few tweaks. Thanks for your help.
A for cinnamon/raisin bread, I have heard that this is tricky due to cinnamon spring down the rise. So if you try it, I’d say incorporate the cinnamon and raisins on the second mix and just be patient with the rising.
I halved the recipe because I've had so many GF bread failures that I didn't want to waste the full amount of ingredients. :(
I'm sure there is something wrong on my end, because in most of the (many) recipes I've tried from GF blogs and cookbooks the dough has been too wet when compared to photos, shaping instructions etc.
However, since this was my first time making this recipe, I used the full amount of liquid. How much would you recommend cutting it back by?
Appreciate your help!
The oat milk should not be a problem. However, if you want to use whole eggs it's not as strong as just the egg white. Adding the yolk actually softens the bread and doesn't contribute as much to the structure. Since this bread is so high in starches it needs the full amount of egg white - I tested it with less egg, and with 100g whole egg, and it didn't hold up.
If the dough is always too wet for you, are you in a humid climate by any chance? That can affect how much moisture to add to the recipe. I had someone try the recipe and they were in Virginia at 70% humidity. They reduced the milk by about 20g and that was about right. I developed this recipe in Oregon and the average humidity here is about 30%.
I hope that helps! Good luck!
Thankyou!!
Tanks for all your efforts to create and support this awesome website. Your site is helping me navigate baking with new-to-me flour and starch blends. This past summer I tested positive for allergies to wheat, rice and egg.
I would love to try this recipe but I need to know how to best substitute the egg white. Is there a reasonable substitute?
Thanks again for this well-written and supported site.
Not sure if my comment/question is attached to the page I was reading,
I’m interested in trying the Homemade Classic White Sandwich Bread
recipe with an egg white substitute. Thank you!
Would you consider adding gluten free sourdough starter to this recipe?
If so, how might you approach it??
Thank you for your thoughts on this.
Pam